| Platinum | Celestino's New York Pizza - 3 Locations |
| Gold | Bodega |
| Silver | Celestino's Pasta & Pizza |
| Bronze | Main Street Pizza |
| Top Pick | Farm Star Pizza |
| Top Pick | Grana |
| Top Pick | Mod Pizza |
| Top Pick | Monstros Pizza & Subs |
| Top Pick | Round Table Pizza |
| Top Pick | Woodstock's Pizza Chico |